Comparison · Updated July 2026
Shipora vs Navidium: same model, different math
Navidium popularized self-managed shipping protection on Shopify: the fee your customer pays stays in your payout, and you handle claims yourself. It earned a 4.9★ rating across 360+ reviews doing it. Shipora runs the same keep-100% model — the differences are what's bundled around it and what you pay for the software.
Side by side
| Shipora | Navidium | |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue model | You keep 100% of fees | You keep 100% of fees |
| Free plan | Yes — gift wrap + 25 protection orders/mo | Yes — up to 50 orders/mo |
| Paid plans | $14.99 / $24.99 flat | Tiered, rises with volume |
| Gift wrap & gift messages | Included, same cart widget | — |
| Priority processing upsell | Included, auto-tags "Priority" | — |
| Claims dashboard | Yes — approve / reship / decline | Yes |
| Cart drawer support | Auto-inject, no theme edits | Widget setup |
| Track record | New (2026) | 4.9★ · 360+ reviews since 2021 |
Where Navidium wins
Track record. Navidium has years in production, hundreds of reviews and a mature feature set for high-volume stores. If you want the most battle-tested app in the self-managed niche and don't care about upsells beyond protection, it's a safe default.
Where Shipora is different
Shipora treats protection as one of three revenue lines in a single cart widget: shipping protection, gift wrap with printed gift messages, and a priority-processing upsell that auto-tags orders for your warehouse. One app, one widget, one flat price — instead of stacking a protection app, a gift-wrap app and an order-tagger. Setup is one click: products, prices and the cart widget are created for you, on cart pages and slide-out drawers alike.
The math, either way
500 orders/month, 40% opt-in at $1.99 ≈ $398 collected. Two $30 claims ≈ $60 out. Both apps leave the ~$338 margin with you — the question is the subscription you pay for the software and how much extra revenue the bundled upsells add. Gift wrap alone typically converts 5–10% of gift-season orders.
Verdict
Both are honest, self-managed models — you can't pick badly here. Pick Navidium for maximum track record. Pick Shipora if you want the same keep-100% economics at a flat price, with gift wrap and priority processing included instead of installed separately.
Coming from a revenue-share app? Read Shipora vs Route or the full list of Route alternatives.
Try Shipora free